The Case Files

Follow the show

Case file No. 273

Ep. 273: Ghostly Voices

Sep 29, 2026 · Runtime 01:01:22 · From the archive

Episode artwork for Ep. 273: Ghostly Voices

Paranormal investigator and author Nicole Tito joins Tinfoil Tales to discuss decades of investigating some of the Midwest's most active haunted locations.

From Resurrection Cemetery outside Chicago to Indiana's historic jails and forgotten buildings, Nicole shares the experiences that have kept her searching for answers. We dive into the Estes Method, EVP research, haunted objects, hitchhiker phenomena, doppelgänger encounters, and why respect is one of the most important rules when investigating the unknown.

Nicole also shares a mysterious audio anomaly she has captured more than 30 times over the course of sixteen years—a strange "screech" recorded on multiple devices at completely different haunted locations that remains unexplained. Along the way, we discuss haunted locations throughout Indiana and Illinois, whether spirits can become attached to objects or people, the risks of provoking unknown entities, and why history should always come before sensationalism when exploring the paranormal.

Is the paranormal simply misunderstood... or are we hearing something that has been watching us all along?

Support the show by becoming a Patreon member for just $1.99 a month. Members get ad free episodes, episodes up to two weeks before they are released, and exclusive content, and it is a huge help in keeping Tinfoil Tales going. Join at patreon.com/tinfoiltales. You can also help the show grow for free: leave a rating and a review on whatever podcast app you use, and share an episode with someone or post about it on social media. Word of mouth really does make a difference.

Have you had a paranormal encounter, seen a cryptid or a UFO, or experienced something you cannot explain? Brandon wants to hear your story. To be a guest on Tinfoil Tales, visit tinfoiltales.com or email tinfoiltalespodcast@gmail.com


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.